1 : MP3
2 : History
2.1 : MP2 and MP3 hit the Internet
3 : Quality of MP3 audio
4 : Bit Rate
5 : Design bugs of MP3
6 : Encoding of MP3 audio
7 : ID3
8 : Alternatives to MP3
9 : Licensing and patent issues
10 : Online music resources
11 : External links
MP3 (or, more precisely, MPEG-1/2 Audio Layer 3) is an audio compression algorithm capable of greatly reducing the amount of data required to reproduce audio, while sounding like a faithful reproduction of the original uncompressed audio to the listener.
History
MPEG-1/2 Layer 2 encoding started life as the Digital Audio Broadcast (DAB) project initiated by Fraunhofer IIS-A. This project was financed by the European Union as a part of the EUREKA research program where it was commonly known as EU-147.
EU-147 ran from 1987 to 1994. In 1991 there were two proposals available: Musicam (known as Layer II) and ASPEC (Adaptive Spectral Perceptual Entropy Coding) (with similarities to MP3). Musicam was chosen due to its simplicity and error resistance.
A working group around Karlheinz Brandenburg and Jürgen Herre
took ideas from Musicam, from ASPEC and own ideas and created MP3, which was designed to achieve the same quality at 128 kbit/s as MP2 at 192 kbit/s.
Both algorithms were finalized in 1992 as part of MPEG-1, the first phase of work by MPEG, which resulted in the international standard ISO/IEC 11172-3, published in 1993. Further work on MPEG Audio was finalized in 1994 as part of the second phase, MPEG-2, which resulted in the international standard ISO/IEC 13818-3, originally published in 1995.
Compression efficiency of lossy encoders is typically defined by the bitrate,
because compression rate depends on bit depth and sampling rate of the input
signal. Nevertheless there are often published compression rates, which
are using the CD parameters as reference (44.1 kHz, 2x16 bit). Sometimes
also the DAT SP parameters are used (48 kHz, 2x16 bit). Compression ratio for
this reference is higher, which demonstrates the problem of the term compression ratio for lossy encoders.
Karlheinz Brandenburg used Suzanne Vega's CD Tom's Diner as his model for the mp3 compression algorithm. This CD was chosen because of its softness and simplicity, making it easier to hear imperfections in the compression format during playbacks.
FhG official webpage publish the following compression ratios and data rates for MPEG-1 Layer 1, 2 and 3:
- Layer 1: 384 kbit/s, compression 4:1
- Layer 2: 192...256 kbit/s, compression 6:1...8:1
- Layer 3: 112...128 kbit/s, compression 10:1...12:1
These values are more or less public relation values, because
- the quality depends not only on the encoding file format, but also on the quality of the psycho acoustic of the encoder. Typical layer 1 encoders use a very simple psycho acoustic which result in a higher needed bitrate for transparent encoding.
- Layer 1 encoding at 384 kbit/s even with this simple psychoacoustic is better than Layer 2 at 192...256 kbit/s
- Layer 3 encoding at 112...128 kbit/s is worse than Layer 2 at 192...256 kbit/s.
More realistic bitrates are:
- Layer 1: excellent at 384 kbit/s
- Layer 2: excellent at 256...320 kbit/s, very good at 224...256 kbit/s, good at 192...224 kbit/s, should not be used below 160 kbit/s
- Layer 3: excellent at 224...256 kbit/s, very good at 192...224 kbit/s, good at 160...192 kbit/s, should not be used below 128 kbit/s
Comparing a new file format typically is done by comparing a medium quality
encoder of the old format and a highly tuned encoder of the new format.
The algorithm of the MP3 format uses, at its heart, a hybrid transform to transform a time domain signal into a frequency domain
signal:
In terms of the MPEG specifications, AAC from MPEG-2 is to be the successor of the MP3 format. In practice, however, due to numerous patenting and licensing issues with various parts of the MPEG specifications, Ogg Vorbis seems positioned to be the mostly likely successor to MP3 as the popular format for audio interchange. Ogg Vorbis is also the format used for sounds in the Wikipedia.
MP2 and MP3 hit the Internet
In October 1993, MP2 (MPEG-1 Audio Layer 2) files appeared on the Internet and were often played back using Xing MPEG Audio Player, and later in a program for UNIX by Tobias Bading called MAPlay initially released on February 22 1994. (MAPlay was also ported to Microsoft Windows.) Initially the only encoder available for MP2 production was the Xing Encoder, accompanied by the program CDDA2WAV, a CD ripper that copied CD audio to hard disks.
Beginning in the first half of 1995, MP3 files, file representations of MPEG-1 Audio Layer III data, began flourishing on the Internet. Its popularity created such companies and software packages as Nullsoft's Winamp, mpg123 and the now Roxio-owned Napster.
Quality of MP3 audio
Many listeners accept the MP3 bitrate of 128 kilobits per second (kbit/s) as near enough to CD quality; this provides a compression ratio of approximately 11:1, although listening tests show that with a bit of practice, most listeners can reliably distinguish 128 kbit/s MP3s from CD originals. To many other listeners, 128 kbit/s is unacceptably low quality, which is unfortunate since many commonly-available encoders set this as their default bitrate.
Possible encoders:
- ISO dist10 reference code: Worse quality, invalid MP3 files (all audio blocks are marked as corrupted)
- Xing: mainly based on ISO code, quality similar to ISO dist10
- Blade: quality similar to ISO dist10
- FhG: Some of them are good, some have really nasty bugs
- ACM Producer Pro: Some versions generate annoying artefacts
- L.A.M.E. (a recursive acronym for "Lame Ain't an MP3 Encoder," founded by Mike Cheng in early 1998) - started life as a GPL'd patch against the dist10 ISO demonstration source, and thus was incapable of producing an mp3 stream or even being compiled by itself. But in May 2000, the last remnants of the ISO source code were replaced, and now LAME is the source code for a fully LGPL'd MP3 encoder, with speed and quality to rival all commercial competitors! Lame
- A Windows frontend for the LAME Encoder can be found at http://jthz.com/mp3/ (the people of JTHZ.com have been working with MP3 since 1998)
- --alt-preset: Alternative presets by Dibrom with good quality at medium bitrates. Dibrom is the nickname of a metal-music fan, who founded http://hydrogenaudio.org/ and introduced some commandline preferences to the LAME developers (now included in the source-code).
Quality of MP3 depends on quality of encoder and the difficulty of the signal which must be encoded. Good encoders gave acceptable quality at 128...160 kbit/s, nearly transparence is achieved at 160...192 kbit/s. Low quality encoders never reach nearly transparence mode, not even at 320 kbit/s. So it is
pointless to speak of 128 kbit/s or 192 kbit/s quality. A 128 kbit/s MP3
encoded with a good encoder might sound better than a 192 kbit/s MP3 file encoded with a bad encoder.
An important feature of MP3 is that it is lossy -- meaning that it removes information from the input in order to save space. As with most modern lossy encoders, MP3 algorithms work hard to ensure that the sounds it removes cannot be detected by human listeners, by modelling chacteristics of human hearing such as noise masking.
However, experienced listeners can tell the difference from the original at 192 kbit/s, and even at 256 kbit/s on some of the less powerful (and obsolete) encoders. If your aim is to archive sound files with no loss of quality, you may be more interested in lossless audio compression such as FLAC, SHN, or LPAC -- these will generally compress a 16-bit PCM audio stream to approximately 50-75% of the original size (depending upon the characteristics of the audio itself).
Bit Rate
The bit rates, i.e. number of binary digits streamed per second, is variable for MP3 files. The general rule is that the higher the bitrate, the more information is included from the original sound file, and thus the higher is the quality of played back audio. In the early days of MP3 encoding, a fixed bit rate was used for the entire file.
Bit rates available in MPEG-1 layer 3 are 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 160, 192, 224, 256 and 320 kbit/s ( bits per second), and the available sample frequencies are 32, 44.1 and 48 kHz. 44.1 kHz is almost always used as this is the audio CD frequency, and 128 Kbit is some sort of de facto "good enough" standard. MPEG-2 and (non-official) MPEG-2.5 adds more bitrates:
8, 16, 24, 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 144, 160 kbit/s.
However, audio in MP3 files are divided into chunks called frames, which all have a bitrate marker, so it is possible to change the bitrate dynamically as the file is played. This technique makes it possible to use more bits for parts of the sound with high dynamics (much "sound movement") and less bits for parts with low dynamics. Some encoders utilize this possibility to greater or lesser extent.
Design bugs of MP3
There are several flaws in the MP3 file format, which cannot be fixed by a good encoder. These flaws are inherent properties of the MP3 file format.
- time resolution is too low for highly transient signals (fixed in AAC, Vorbis)
- encoder/decoder overall delay is not defined (fixed in Vorbis)
- no scaleband factor for frequencies above 15.5/15.8 kHz (fixed in AAC, Vorbis)
- joint stereo is done on a frame base (fixed in AAC, Vorbis)
- bitrate is limited to 320 kbit/s (fixed in AAC, Vorbis)
Encoding of MP3 audio
The MPEG-1 standard does not include a precise specification for an MP3 encoder. The decoding algorithm and file format, as a contrast, are well defined. Implementors of the standard were supposed to devise their own algorithms suitable for removing parts of the information in the raw audio (or rather its MDCT representation in the frequency domain). This process is typically based on psycho-acoustic coding, i.e., you remove things that a human listener will not notice anyway by modeling our audio perception system (both in our ears and in our brain).
As a result, there are many different MP3 encoders available, each producing files of differing quality; as of September 30, 2001, the best encoder at high bitrates (128 kbit/s and up) is LAME, and the better one at low bitrates is said to be Fraunhofer's own encoder, although opinions vary. MP3 decoding, however, is carefully defined in the standard. Most decoders are "bitstream compliant", meaning that they will each produce exactly the same uncompressed output from a given MP3 file.
ID3
See main article ID3
ID3 is a tagging format that allows information such as the title, artist, album, or track number of the MP3 to be added to the file.
Alternatives to MP3
Many other lossy audio codecs exist, including:
mp3PRO, MP3, AAC, and MP2 are all members of the same technological family and depend on roughly similar psychoacoustic models. The Fraunhofer Gesellschaft owns many of the basic patents underlying these codecs, with Dolby Labs, Sony, Thomson Consumer Electronics, and AT&T holding other key patents.
There are also some non-lossy (lossless) audio compression methods used on the internet. While they are not similar to MP3, they are good examples of other compression schemes available. These include:
MP3, which was designed and tuned for use alongside MPEG-1/2 Video, generally performs poorly on monaural data at less than 48 kbit/s or in stereo at less than 80 kbit/s.
Though proponents of newer codecs such as WMA and RealAudio have asserted that their respective algorithms can achieve CD quality at 64 kbit/s, listening tests have shown otherwise; however, the quality of these codecs at 64 kbit/s is definitely superior to MP3 at the same bandwidth.
Thomson claims that its mp3PRO codec achieves CD quality at 64 kbit/s, but listeners have reported that a 64 kbit/s mp3PRO file compares in quality to a 112 kbit/s MP3 file and does not come reasonably close to CD quality until about 80 kbit/s.
The Xiph.org Foundation (the developers of the Vorbis algorithm used in the new Ogg format) has proven that Vorbis surpasses MP3 and WMA Standard sound quality, and provide a web page with listening tests to demonstrate this.
Licensing and patent issues
Thomson Consumer Electronics controls licensing of the MPEG-1/2 Layer 3 patents in countries such as the United States of America and Japan that recognize software patents. Thomson has decided to attempt to collect royalties for the patents. In fact Microsoft, the makers of the Windows operating system, chose to move away from MP3 to their own proprietary Windows Media formats to avoid the licensing issues associated with the patents.
In September 1998, the Fraunhofer Institute sent a letter to several developers of MP3 software stating that a license was required to "distribute and/or sell decoders and/or encoders". The letter claimed that unlicensed products "infringe the patent rights of Fraunhofer and THOMSON. To make, sell and/or distribute products using the [MPEG Layer-3] standard and thus our patents, you need to obtain a license under these patents from us." This significantly slowed the development of unlicensed MP3 software and led to increased focus on alternatives, including the creation of Ogg Vorbis.
For information about licensing fees see [1] and [2].
In spite of the patent restrictions, the perpetuation of the MP3 format continues; the reasons for this appear to be the network effects caused by:
- familiarity with the format,
- the large quantity of music now available in the MP3 format,
- the wide variety of existing software and hardware that takes advantage of the file format that revolutionized the music industry and copyright law.
Online music resources
One of the largest repositories of freely downloadable MP3 music is the MP3.com archive, which is now hosted by CNET. Tools such as iRate try to make it easier to find music that matches the listener's tastes. There are several online music stores. Apple's iTunes store is presently the most popular commercial online music offering. A controversial MP3 portal is the Russian site AllOfMP3.com, which offers downloads of thousands of albums and video clips by mainstream artists, priced at $10 per gigabyte.
External links
|